Tag: Del. Ch. R. 41(b)

1
Charter Communications Operating, LLC v. Optymze, LLC (Del. Ch. 2021)

Charter Communications Operating, LLC v. Optymze, LLC (Del. Ch. 2021)

Key Insight: Defendant committed serious misconduct sufficient to justify dismissal of its counterclaims under Rule 41(b). Defendant refused the reasonable request for native files exchanged via Microsoft Teams. Defendant produced individual emails containing each message. In this format, the messages could not be reassembled into complete conversations. Defendant was compelled to produce the native files which revealed extensive spoliation of evidence. Defendant edited numerous chat messages in an effort to hide instructions to employees to take actions that violated court orders. Because all of the unaddressed misconduct related to Defendant’s counterclaims, dismissal of those counterclaims with prejudice and award of fees and expenses is an adequate remedy.

Nature of Case: Breach of Contract

Electronic Data Involved: Instant message

Case Summary

Copyright © 2022, K&L Gates LLP. All Rights Reserved.