Hurley v. BMW of N. Am. LLC (E.D. Pa. Apr. 27, 2021)
Key Insight: The three categories of documents sought by Plaintiff are relevant to the litigation. Further, production of the three categories of documents would not be disproportionate to the needs of the litigation. Production of the documents, which had already been digitized and indexed (and produced) for previous litigation, would be of little expense and/or burden to Defendant. The burden and/or expense of producing the documents do not outweigh the likely benefits of production.
Nature of Case: Product Defects
Electronic Data Involved: Digitized and indexed manuals and other documents