Catagory:Case Summaries

1
Sloan Valve Co. v. Zurn Indus., Inc., No. 10-cv-204, 2012 WL 1886353 (N.D. Ill. May 23, 2012)
2
In re M., No. 09-12-00179-CV, 2012 WL 1808236 (Tex. Ct. App. May 17, 2012)
3
Biselli v Cnty. of Ventura, No. CV 09-08694 CAS (EX), 2012 WL 2061688 (C.D. Cal. June 4, 2012)
4
Domanus v. Lewicki, No. 08 C 4922, 2012 WL 2072866 (N.D. Ill. June 8, 2012)
5
In re Toyota Motor Corp. Unintended Acceleration Mktg. Sales Practices, and Prods. Liability Litig., —F. Supp. 2d—, 2012 WL 2146319 (C.D. Cal. June 11, 2012)
6
Illiana Surgery and Med. Ctr., No. 2:07 cv 3, 2012 WL 2049828 (N.D. Ind. June 5, 2012)
7
Goldstein v. Colborne Acquisition Co., No. 10 C 6861, 2012 WL 1969369 (N.D. Ill. June 1, 2012)
8
Tadayon v. Greyhound Lines, Inc, No. 10-1326, 2012 WL 2048257 (D.D.C. June 6, 2012)
9
Ceglia v. Zuckerberg, No. 10-CV-00569A(F), 2012 WL 95362 (W.D.N.Y. Jan. 10, 2012)
10
Tourgeman v. Collins Fin. Servs., Inc., No. 08cv1392-JLS(NLS), 2012 WL 28289 (S.D. Cal. Jan. 5, 2012)

Sloan Valve Co. v. Zurn Indus., Inc., No. 10-cv-204, 2012 WL 1886353 (N.D. Ill. May 23, 2012)

Key Insight: Finding defendants? search efforts inadequate, court ordered discovery re-opened and that defendant conduct specific additional discovery, including additional searches on specific repositories, and provide specific information regarding how its search efforts were conducted and by whom; the court also provided a good discussion of preservation obligations, but ultimately concluded that additional information was necessary to make a determination regarding the reasonableness of defendants efforts; ultimately, court declined to impose drastic sanctions, but ordered additional discovery and that defendants pay monetary sanctions (attorneys? fees and cost)

Nature of Case: Patent infringement

Electronic Data Involved: ESI

In re M., No. 09-12-00179-CV, 2012 WL 1808236 (Tex. Ct. App. May 17, 2012)

Key Insight: The appellate court held that the trial court had erred in admitting appellant?s cellular phone into evidence and in granting opposing counsels? oral motion for forensic examination of that phone where the phone was initially surrendered by appellant to allow for the reading of particular, relevant, messages and not requested by a formal discovery request as is required by law, where appellant had no opportunity to object to the scope of the production or to assert his privileges and where the rules of discovery require the least intrusive means of retrieval and direct access to devices is discouraged

Nature of Case: Child custody

Electronic Data Involved: Cellular phone and contents

Biselli v Cnty. of Ventura, No. CV 09-08694 CAS (EX), 2012 WL 2061688 (C.D. Cal. June 4, 2012)

Key Insight: Where defendant had an obligation to preserve relevant video and in fact ?acknowledged? plaintiff?s request to preserve the video by objecting to it, court held that defendant had an obligation to preserve the requested evidence ?including a duty to deactivate any automatic purging policy? that defendant claimed resulted in the loss and ordered an adverse inference at trial with the potential for additional sanctions to be imposed later

Nature of Case: Claims resulting from suicide of inmate

Electronic Data Involved: surveillance video

Domanus v. Lewicki, No. 08 C 4922, 2012 WL 2072866 (N.D. Ill. June 8, 2012)

Key Insight: Where defendants indicated that a relevant hard drive had crashed and been disposed of but that some relevant information had been recovered and where plaintiff was unable to establish that defendants acted in bad faith, court found defendants were grossly negligent in their failure to preserve the relevant hard drive which resulted in prejudice to the plaintiff and ordered a ?spoliation charge? allowing but not requiring the jury to determine whether the spoliation warranted an adverse inference; opinion includes comprehensive discussion of relevant law and standards surrounding spoliation

Nature of Case: Racketeering and fraud

Electronic Data Involved: Hard drive

In re Toyota Motor Corp. Unintended Acceleration Mktg. Sales Practices, and Prods. Liability Litig., —F. Supp. 2d—, 2012 WL 2146319 (C.D. Cal. June 11, 2012)

Key Insight: Where Toyota conducted inspection of relevant Event Data Recorder without providing plaintiffs the opportunity to be present but where there was no showing of actual alteration or deletion of relevant data, court declined to impose terminating sanctions and ordered a cautionary instruction be given to the jury; court also credited plaintiff?s evidence regarding a dispute surrounding the location of a plastic piece in plaintiffs? engine, which was allegedly moved by Toyota representatives during their inspection, and ordered an evidentiary instruction stating that the Toyota representatives testimony regarding the plastic piece should be regarded with ?greater caution? than that of other witnesses

Nature of Case: Personal injury/product liability

Electronic Data Involved: Event Data Recorder data and plastic piece in engine

Illiana Surgery and Med. Ctr., No. 2:07 cv 3, 2012 WL 2049828 (N.D. Ind. June 5, 2012)

Key Insight: Court granted motion to compel defendant to designate a 30(b)(6) deponent to be deposed regarding defendant?s method of maintaining electronically stored information during the relevant time period where the information was relevant to plaintiff?s claims of bad faith and where defendant had produced requested information in a piecemeal fashion and repeatedly supplemented production, despite previously claiming all relevant information had been produced

Nature of Case: Breach of insurance contract and bad faith

Electronic Data Involved: Deponent to testify regarding document management practices

Goldstein v. Colborne Acquisition Co., No. 10 C 6861, 2012 WL 1969369 (N.D. Ill. June 1, 2012)

Key Insight: President and owner of corporation waived privileged as to emails on company servers by consenting to the sale of all company assets, including the company?s servers and emails, without asserting his privilege; shareholders/officers of corporation waived privilege as to messages sent from company email where subjective belief that their communications were confidential was not reasonable in light of company?s email policy which claimed ownership of emails on company systems and reserved the right to access them; court?s analysis applied Asia Global Crossing factors, but acknowledged that privilege waiver inquiries require case-by-case analysis

Nature of Case: Claim of fraudulent sale of business to avoid judgment

Electronic Data Involved: Allegedly privileged emails

Tadayon v. Greyhound Lines, Inc, No. 10-1326, 2012 WL 2048257 (D.D.C. June 6, 2012)

Key Insight: In this case, following analysis of several discovery motions, Magistrate Judge Facciola wrote of the need for cooperation: “III. High Noon. As explained at the discovery status hearing held on April 30, 2012, there is a new sheriff in town-not Gary Cooper, but me. The filing of forty-page discovery motions accompanied by thousands of pages of exhibits will cease and will now be replaced by a new regimen in which the parties, without surrendering any of their rights, must make genuine efforts to engage in the cooperative discovery regimen contemplated by the Sedona Conference Cooperation Proclamation.FN3 First, the parties will meet and confer in person in a genuine, good faith effort. . . .”; also, court ruled that where Clawback agreement imposed no conditions on right to recall privileged documents, defendant could do so irrespective of alleged negligence

Nature of Case: Patent Infringement

Electronic Data Involved: All discovery

Ceglia v. Zuckerberg, No. 10-CV-00569A(F), 2012 WL 95362 (W.D.N.Y. Jan. 10, 2012)

Key Insight: Where plaintiff acted to avoid compliance with court?s order to produce information related to email accounts, including passwords, by repeatedly filing motions to stay discovery and by modifying the consent forms related to the examination of his email accounts to effectively delay the search, despite the court?s denial of his motions to stay discovery, the court ordered civil contempt sanctions and ordered plaintiff to pay $5,000 to the court and also ordered payment of defendants? attorneys? fees and costs related to Defendants? Accelerated Motion to Compel, necessitated by plaintiff?s dilatory behavior

Nature of Case: Breach of contract

Electronic Data Involved: Access to emails (passwords, etc.) for forensic examination

Tourgeman v. Collins Fin. Servs., Inc., No. 08cv1392-JLS(NLS), 2012 WL 28289 (S.D. Cal. Jan. 5, 2012)

Key Insight: Where defendants? mistake in searching resulted in the failure to produce relevant documents and where plaintiff alleged that those documents would have established numerosity for purposes of his motion to certify (and where the motion was denied without them), court found that the mistake was not willful or in bad faith and that there was no prejudice where plaintiff was free to re-file his motion and thus, as a sanction, awarded limited attorneys? fees incurred as the result of defendants? mistake and noted plaintiff?s failure to timely review the documents produced by defendants, which may have alerted him to the problems prior to filing his motion for class certification

Nature of Case: Class action

Electronic Data Involved: ESI

Copyright © 2026, K&L Gates LLP. All Rights Reserved.