O?Neill v. City of Shoreline, 240 P.3d 1149 (Wash. 2010)
Key Insight: Metadata is subject to disclosure pursuant to the Public Records Act
Nature of Case: Public Disclosure Act
Electronic Data Involved: Metadata
Key Insight: Metadata is subject to disclosure pursuant to the Public Records Act
Nature of Case: Public Disclosure Act
Electronic Data Involved: Metadata
Key Insight: Where defendants resisted production of electronically stored information and sought to shift the costs of such production to plaintiff by presenting affidavits and expert testimony regarding the expected cost of production which, in large part, was the result of defendants? lack of a data retrieval system for archived information and its failure to suspend archiving documents despite the commencement of related litigation in 2004, and where it was revealed that the expert testimony presented lacked sufficient foundation, the court held that defendants had acted in bad faith and could no longer be trusted and awarded plaintiffs? fees and costs in the amount of $42,978.43; affirmed on appeal
Nature of Case: Violation of False Claims Act
Electronic Data Involved: Archived ESI
Key Insight: Court granted in part plaintiff?s motion in limine and imposed an adverse inference resulting from defendant?s failure to preserve surveillance video tape potentially containing footage of the underlying accident upon finding that defendant was aware of its duty to preserve but took no steps to prevent the footage from being automatically recorded over; court denied request for default judgment where such a drastic step was not warranted absent evidence of the ?requisite willfulness, fault, or bad faith?; court declined to impose monetary sanctions
Nature of Case: Personal injury/slip and fall
Electronic Data Involved: Video surveillance tape
Key Insight: For CFO?s intentional destruction of evidence to defeat litigation despite a duty to preserve, the district court judge adopted the magistrate judge?s recommendation and imposed a $100,000 fine and found that more drastic sanctions were not warranted where the resulting prejudice was mitigated by the availability of all the defendants and other witnesses for questioning
Nature of Case: Tortious interference with business relationships, misappropriation of trade secrets, unfair competition
Electronic Data Involved: Emails
Key Insight: Where the court found that defendant?s source code?s metadata ?(i.e. programmer?s notes or comments and other annotations in the source code) ? may be relevant to [plaintiff?s] claims,? the court ordered defendant to produce the metadata but indicated that it could redact the actual source code from the production and produce the metadata subject to the parties? stipulated protective order
Nature of Case: Misappropriation of business ideas, false advertising, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud
Electronic Data Involved: Metadata for source code ?(i.e. programmer?s notes or comments and other annotations in the source code)”
Key Insight: Where plaintiff sought the unredacted source code of defendant?s allegedly infringing products, the court credited plaintiff?s expert testimony that because source code ?generally contains notes by the writer of that code ?that explain to others who come later what the [writer] of the code was trying to accomplish at that portion of the code??, all of the source code was necessary to ensure his correct understanding of all portions and ordered plaintiff to produce the source code pursuant to the parties protective order; in so holding, court noted that ?the dilemma? of having to produce source court for unrelated products was of defendant?s ?own making? because of its business practice of bundling the source code for all of its products together
Nature of Case: Patent infringement
Electronic Data Involved: Source code
Key Insight: Where plaintiff presented evidence that searching for the information requested by defendants could exceed 400 hours and where the request was duplicative and other sources of information existed, the court found that ?the burden on plaintiff ? is heavier than Defendants? alleged need for the files warrants? and granted plaintiff?s request for a Protective Order
Nature of Case: Claims for misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of the duty of loyalty and breach of contract, among others
Electronic Data Involved: ESI/customer files
Key Insight: Trial court did not abuse discretion in dismissing plaintiff?s claims as sanction for spoliation where plaintiff failed to preserve evidence and in fact purposefully acted to destroy evidence by utilizing scrubbing software and taking other deliberate measures
Nature of Case: Plaintiffs brought suit to recover losses based on a breach of fiduciary duty, wrongful termination, and indemnification
Electronic Data Involved: Contents of plaintiff’s computer
Key Insight: For plaintiff?s willful and bad faith violations of the court?s orders which resulted in prejudice to the defendants, including unexplained delays in production and intentional deletion of files on computers which the court had ordered no one to use, and where the court had previously warned that failure to comply could result in dismissal, court ordered dismissal of plaintiff?s claims
Nature of Case: Cross claims arising from insurance payments for home health care
Electronic Data Involved: ESI
Key Insight: Where defendants denied plaintiffs? spoliation allegations and opposed their motion for sanctions by asserting that all responsive emails had been produced, court ordered defendants to comply with a prior order requiring defense counsel to submit a declaration indicating whether any relevant ESI had been withheld and why and to provide a privilege log for any such documents and to provide a privilege log for three emails previously submitted for in camera review; failure to submit the declaration or the privilege log by a date certain would result in a $500 sanction for each violation
Nature of Case: Employment litigation
Electronic Data Involved: Emails
Copyright © 2026, K&L Gates LLP. All Rights Reserved.