Electronic Discovery Law
Sanctions Not Warranted for Failure to Preserve Voicemail Messages
Burrell v. Anderson, 353 F.Supp.2d 55 (D. Me. 2005)
Plaintiff sued county and various employees of police department and attorney general's office alleging due process, equal protection, First Amendment, and civil rights conspiracy claims stemming from incidents involving either plaintiff and his former girlfriend, or their daughter. Plaintiff contended that the defendant employees improperly responded or unacceptably failed to respond to these incidents because of gender-discriminatory attitudes and policies pertaining to domestic abuse.
Defendants moved for summary judgment, and plaintiff filed a motion for sanctions in addition to his opposition to the motions. Plaintiff claimed that several of the individual defendants had failed to preserve voicemail messages left by plaintiff which, plaintiff adamantly contended, they should have known plaintiff would need "to prove that he was not being abusive in leaving the messages and that he was indeed complaining of matters of great public concern."
The court summarily denied the motion for sanctions, stating: "Apropos Burrell's contention that any of the defendants had a duty to keep recordings of his voicemail messages in order to preserve evidence favorable to Burrell in this civil litigation, I outright reject this notion." The court noted that plaintiff's pleadings gave "a pretty thorough picture" of what plaintiff's concerns were at the time he left the messages and what he deemed to be matters of "'great public concern.'" The court also dropped a footnote observing: "If Burrell thought that it should have been so evident to the defendants that Burrell would need a copy of Burrell's one-sided messages it should have been evident to Burrell himself. In view of the recordings of conversations that Burrell has submitted it is a wonder to me that he did not record his messages on his own."
K&L Gates includes lawyers practicing out of more than 40 fully integrated offices located in North America, Europe, Asia, South America, and the Middle East, and represents numerous GLOBAL 500, FORTUNE 100, and FTSE 100 corporations, in addition to growth and middle market companies, entrepreneurs, capital market participants and public sector entities. For more information about K&L Gates or its locations and registrations, visit www.klgates.com.
Portions of this Web site may contain Attorney Advertising under the rules of some states. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
e-Discovery Analysis & Technology group at K&L Gates, offering services related to ediscovery, review of electronic documents, electronic discovery and electronic evidence discovery.
K&L Gates LLP
925 Fourth Avenue, Suite 2900, Seattle, Washington 98104-1158
p. 206.623.7580, f. 206.623.7022